| 2016 Tier 3 Award Finalists | |||||
| Top 3 Vote Getters (including Ties) | |||||
| - alphabetical order (last name) | |||||
| All Award winners to be announced at the Annual Awards Banquet on November 4th | |||||
| Most Valuable Player | |||||
| Phil Martin | Black Sox | ||||
| Jay Murfitt | Sharks | ||||
| Jeremy Pluym | Mavericks | ||||
| Best Batter | |||||
| Stephane Leclair | Dukes | ||||
| Jay Murfitt | Sharks | ||||
| Joel Sanscartier | Lumberjacks | ||||
| Best Pitcher | |||||
| Dave Farquharson | Bytown Bombers | ||||
| Nick Lenardon | REMAX Rockets | ||||
| Phil Martin | Black Sox | ||||
| Jon Smith | Red Sox | ||||
| Jeremy Pluym | Mavericks | ||||
| Sportsmanship and Ability | |||||
| Mike Bayley | REMAX Rockets | ||||
| Jonathan Dotzko | Mavericks | ||||
| Chris Goguen | Sharks | ||||
| Trevor Williams | Dukes | ||||